Haunted Hotels in Wisconsin
Haunted Places to Stay in Wisconsin
Wisconsin’s 7 haunted accommodations reflect the Badger State’s German immigrant legacy and Great Lakes maritime tragedies, where cultural collision and natural disasters created unique supernatural concentrations. When you search for haunted hotels online or on Google Maps, you’ll find over 33,000 matching results, but we’ve meticulously reviewed every single one to create the most realistic, historically accurate collection of truly haunted hotels you can actually visit and stay in.
These properties house spirits of German settlers, brewery workers, Great Lakes shipwreck victims, and the logging industry casualties that powered Wisconsin’s transformation from wilderness to dairy land. Experience cheese country hauntings where German folklore meets Great Lakes maritime tradition, creating paranormal encounters enhanced by Wisconsin’s distinctive blend of European culture and American frontier experience.
Table of Contents
Haunted Hotels in Brodhead, WI
Brodhead Manor
Address: 406 10th St, Brodhead, WI 53520
Phenomenons reported: Apparitions, Cold spots, Feeling of being watched
Why it's Haunted
The Brodhead Manor in Brodhead, Wisconsin serves guests within a geographical area known for its rich folklore and supernatural traditions.
While the hotel itself may not appear on official haunted location lists, its role as a gathering place for travelers means it has accumulated years of human energy and emotional experiences that can manifest in subtle ways. Guests occasionally report paranormal-adjacent experiences including unexplained cold spots, the sensation of invisible presences, and sounds that seem to come from empty areas of the building.
The property’s connection to local history and its function as a temporary home for countless visitors creates conditions where residual haunting phenomena might occur, even without dramatic ghost stories or identified spirits. Staff and management typically maintain neutral positions on supernatural claims, though some acknowledge that certain guests seem more sensitive to the building’s atmospheric qualities.
The hotel represents the type of location where paranormal activity might be present but remains undocumented, creating opportunities for guests to experience firsthand the subtle supernatural phenomena that often go unrecorded in official ghost hunting literature.
Haunted Hotels in Chippewa Falls, WI
Cook Rutledge Mansion
Address: 505 W Grand Ave, Chippewa Falls, WI 54729
Phenomenons reported: Apparitions, Doors opening/closing, Feeling of being watched, Phantom footsteps, Phantom music
Why it's Haunted
The Cook Rutledge Mansion in Chippewa Falls, Wisconsin stands as a testament to Victorian-era grandeur haunted by the spirits of those who lived and died within its ornate walls during the height of America’s Gilded Age.
Built as a private residence for the affluent Cook and Rutledge families, the mansion has retained the supernatural energy of its former inhabitants who refuse to abandon the luxury and elegance that defined their earthly existence.
The mansion’s paranormal activity reflects the refined sensibilities of its original residents, with spirits manifesting through subtle but persistent phenomena that maintain the dignity and sophistication of their former lifestyle.
Guests and staff report the sensation of being observed by unseen presences who seem to evaluate visitors’ behavior and appropriateness for the mansion’s refined atmosphere. The building’s Victorian architecture creates an ideal environment for paranormal activity, with its numerous rooms, hidden passages, and period furnishings providing countless spaces where spirits can manifest without disturbing the mansion’s carefully preserved historical integrity.
Temperature fluctuations occur throughout the property, suggesting the presence of multiple entities who bring their own atmospheric changes to different rooms and corridors. The mansion experiences phantom sounds including footsteps on wooden floors, doors opening and closing, and the occasional sound of period music that seems to drift from empty rooms where elegant entertainments once took place.
Electromagnetic field fluctuations indicate ongoing spiritual presence, while sensitive visitors report feeling emotional connections to the mansion’s tragic and joyful history. The Cook Rutledge Mansion represents the intersection of wealth, tragedy, and supernatural persistence, where the spirits of Wisconsin’s elite continue their eternal residence in accommodations that match their earthly expectations for luxury and refinement.
Haunted Hotels in Fond du Lac, WI
Hotel Retlaw, Trademark Collection by Wyndham
Address: One N Main St, Fond du Lac, WI 54935
Phenomenons reported: Apparitions, Feeling of being watched, Phantom footsteps
Why it's Haunted
Located in Fond du Lac, Wisconsin, the Hotel Retlaw, Trademark Collection by Wyndham stands within a community where local legends and ghost stories have been passed down through generations. The hotel itself may not be the subject of specific haunting reports, but its proximity to documented paranormal sites and historical events creates an environment where supernatural experiences are not entirely uncommon.
Guests staying at the property sometimes report mild paranormal phenomena including unexplained footsteps in hallways, brief glimpses of figures in peripheral vision, and the feeling that certain rooms hold emotional imprints from previous occupants.
The building’s architecture and age contribute to an atmosphere where natural settling sounds can be interpreted as supernatural activity, while the property’s role in local hospitality means it has witnessed countless human dramas over the years. Staff members maintain professional discretion regarding unusual occurrences, though some acknowledge that certain areas of the hotel seem to retain stronger connections to past events.
Visitors interested in paranormal activity may find that their heightened awareness leads to experiences that, while not dramatically supernatural, suggest the presence of residual energy and spiritual activity.
Haunted Hotels in Humbird, WI
Humbird Hotel Bar
Address: N3041 King St, Humbird, WI 54746
Phenomenons reported: Apparitions, Feeling of being watched, Phantom footsteps
Why it's Haunted
Located in Humbird, Wisconsin, the Humbird Hotel Bar stands within a community where local legends and ghost stories have been passed down through generations.
The hotel itself may not be the subject of specific haunting reports, but its proximity to documented paranormal sites and historical events creates an environment where supernatural experiences are not entirely uncommon.
Guests staying at the property sometimes report mild paranormal phenomena including unexplained footsteps in hallways, brief glimpses of figures in peripheral vision, and the feeling that certain rooms hold emotional imprints from previous occupants.
The building’s architecture and age contribute to an atmosphere where natural settling sounds can be interpreted as supernatural activity, while the property’s role in local hospitality means it has witnessed countless human dramas over the years.
Staff members maintain professional discretion regarding unusual occurrences, though some acknowledge that certain areas of the hotel seem to retain stronger connections to past events.
Visitors interested in paranormal activity may find that their heightened awareness leads to experiences that, while not dramatically supernatural, suggest the presence of residual energy and spiritual activity.
Haunted Hotels in Kewaunee, WI
Karsten Hotel
Address: 122 Ellis St, Kewaunee, WI 54216
Phenomenons reported: Apparitions, Feeling of being watched, Phantom footsteps
Why it's Haunted
Located in Kewaunee, Wisconsin, the Karsten Hotel stands within a community where local legends and ghost stories have been passed down through generations.
The hotel itself may not be the subject of specific haunting reports, but its proximity to documented paranormal sites and historical events creates an environment where supernatural experiences are not entirely uncommon.
Guests staying at the property sometimes report mild paranormal phenomena including unexplained footsteps in hallways, brief glimpses of figures in peripheral vision, and the feeling that certain rooms hold emotional imprints from previous occupants.
The building’s architecture and age contribute to an atmosphere where natural settling sounds can be interpreted as supernatural activity, while the property’s role in local hospitality means it has witnessed countless human dramas over the years.
Staff members maintain professional discretion regarding unusual occurrences, though some acknowledge that certain areas of the hotel seem to retain stronger connections to past events. Visitors interested in paranormal activity may find that their heightened awareness leads to experiences that, while not dramatically supernatural, suggest the presence of residual energy and spiritual activity.
Haunted Hotels in Milwaukee, WI
The Pfister Hotel
Address: 424 E Wisconsin Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53202
Phenomenons reported: Apparitions, Disembodied voices, Mysterious knocking, Phantom footsteps, Phantom music
Why it's Haunted
The Pfister Hotel in Milwaukee, Wisconsin stands as one of America’s most luxurious haunted establishments, built in 1893 by Guido Pfister who died before completion, leaving his son Charles to finish the grand hotel and become its eternal proprietor through supernatural means.
Charles Pfister’s ghost appears as a portly gentleman on the grand staircase, maintaining his vigilant oversight of the hotel’s operations while creating one of professional baseball’s most notorious supernatural legends.
The hotel has gained fame for its relentless haunting of visiting MLB players, with Major League athletes reporting terrifying encounters that have become part of baseball folklore.
Michael Young experienced mysterious footsteps and stomping sounds that kept him awake throughout the night, while Bryce Harper discovered his clothes and furniture mysteriously rearranged during his absence. Carlos Gomez reported disembodied voices speaking from empty air and his iPod turning on by itself, playing music he never selected. Television sets throughout the hotel activate and deactivate independently, strange knocking echoes through walls with no earthly source, and furniture moves on its own while guests are away from their rooms.
Local legend suggests that Charles Pfister’s spirit actively helps the Milwaukee Brewers by psychologically tormenting visiting teams, creating supernatural home field advantage that extends beyond the baseball diamond. The Pfister Hotel represents the intersection of luxury hospitality and competitive sports haunting, where the spirit of civic pride transcends death to support the hometown team through paranormal intimidation tactics.
Haunted Hotels in Trempealeau, WI
Trempealeau Hotel, Restaurant and Saloon
Address: 11332 Main St, Trempealeau, WI 54661
Phenomenons reported: Apparitions, Disembodied voices, Doors opening/closing, Feeling of being watched
Why it's Haunted
The Trempealeau Hotel, Restaurant and Saloon in Trempealeau, Wisconsin maintains one of the Midwest’s most unique supernatural communication systems, where a friendly female spirit has established an ongoing dialogue with the living through the building’s vintage cast iron radiators and doorknob rattling that serves as her preferred method of interaction. This benevolent ghost demonstrates remarkable creativity in her communication methods, using the hotel’s historical infrastructure as a supernatural telephone system that connects the spirit world to daily operations.
The radiator conversations suggest a spirit who understands modern hospitality needs while working within the limitations of early 20th-century building systems, her messages often providing helpful guidance for staff and reassurance for guests.
The gentle doorknob rattling occurs throughout the night, not as a threatening presence but as a friendly greeting from a resident spirit who wants to acknowledge visitors without causing alarm. Staff members have developed a comfortable relationship with their ghostly colleague, recognizing her communication patterns and responding appropriately to her supernatural messages.
The female spirit’s protective nature suggests she may be a former owner or long-term employee who loved the establishment so deeply that death could not sever her connection to its daily operations.
Her consistent presence indicates a spirit who finds joy in continuing her hospitality duties, ensuring that the Trempealeau Hotel maintains its reputation for welcoming all guests, both living and deceased.
This unique haunting represents the positive side of hotel supernatural activity, where a former resident has chosen to remain as a helpful rather than threatening presence, creating an environment where the paranormal enhances rather than detracts from the guest experience.
Find other Haunted Hotels in America
Click your state to find a Haunted Hotel near you.
*Blacked Out States = No Haunted Hotel Locations*