Haunted Hotels in Ohio
Haunted Places to Stay in Ohio
Ohio’s 9 haunted accommodations reflect the Buckeye State’s role as the Underground Railroad’s northern terminus, where freedom seekers and industrial progress created unique supernatural concentrations. When you search for haunted hotels online or on Google Maps, you’ll find over 33,000 matching results, but we’ve meticulously reviewed every single one to create the most realistic, historically accurate collection of truly haunted hotels you can actually visit and stay in.
These properties preserve spirits of escaped slaves, abolitionist martyrs, Civil War volunteers, and the industrial casualties that powered Ohio’s transformation from frontier to manufacturing center. Experience Midwestern hauntings where abolitionist sacrifice meets industrial innovation, creating paranormal encounters that reflect Ohio’s pivotal role in America’s moral and economic development.
Table of Contents
Haunted Hotels in Loudonville, OH
Landoll's Mohican Castle - Luxury Hotel in Central Ohio
Address: 561 Township Road 3352, Loudonville, OH 44842
Phenomenons reported: Lady in White apparition, Military/soldier spirits, EVP recordings, Apparitions, Disembodied voices, Doors opening/closing
Why it's Haunted
Landoll’s Mohican Castle in Loudonville, Ohio harbors multiple spirits from its 200-year-old cemetery, including Civil War soldiers who died from their wounds and young Samantha Carnagey who succumbed to typhoid.
Featured on A&E’s Ghost Hunters, the castle’s most notorious spirit is the malevolent Lady in White, who appears above guests’ beds glaring menacingly and has been independently sketched identically by three separate witnesses. Her hostile presence escalated to dangerous levels when she began turning fireplaces to full blast, creating fire hazards that prompted paranormal intervention.
Samantha’s spirit, wearing her distinctive blue dress, plays in the graveyard during winter and laughs in the pool area, with her voice captured on EVP recordings saying ‘hello’ to guests. The Stone Cottage, deemed the most haunted structure on the property, experiences constant paranormal activity including voices, phantom footsteps, kitchen drawers opening independently, and apparitions on the deck.
The castle offers guided ghost walks and private investigations, granting access to the underground tunnel, the authentic Heyd’s cabin, and the historic cemetery where bodies were relocated before the original church mysteriously burned to the ground.
Haunted Hotels in Cincinnati, OH
Hilton Cincinnati Netherland Plaza
Address: 35 W 5th St, Cincinnati, OH 45202
Phenomenons reported: Apparitions, Cold spots, Doors opening/closing, Elevator malfunctions, Feeling of being watched, Mirror phenomena
Why it's Haunted
The Hilton Cincinnati Netherland Plaza, an Art Deco masterpiece opened in 1931, stands as one of Cincinnati’s most elegant and reportedly haunted hotels.
This National Historic Landmark has witnessed decades of glamorous events and tragic incidents that have left paranormal imprints throughout its opulent halls.
Staff and guests report encounters with the Lady in Green, a mysterious woman in 1930s attire who glides through the mezzanine level and vanishes when approached. The Hall of Mirrors ballroom hosts phantom jazz music and ghostly dancers from the hotel’s golden age, with witnesses describing couples waltzing to unheard melodies.
Former construction workers who died during the building’s construction are believed to haunt the basement levels, where maintenance staff hear phantom hammering and witness tools moving on their own. Room 930 experiences unexplained temperature drops and guests report feeling an invisible presence sitting on their beds.
The Brazilian rosewood-paneled bar echoes with phantom laughter and clinking glasses after closing, while elevators mysteriously travel to floors without being summoned, suggesting the presence of long-deceased bellhops still attending to their eternal duties.
Haunted Hotels in Marietta, OH
Lafayette Hotel
Address: 101 Front St, Marietta, OH 45750
Phenomenons reported: Apparitions, Child spirits, Doors opening/closing, Electrical disturbances, Feeling of being watched, Phantom footsteps
Why it's Haunted
The Lafayette Hotel in Marietta, Ohio stands as one of the state’s most haunted establishments, built in 1918 on the site of the tragic Bellevue Hotel fire of 1916 that claimed 13 lives.
The third floor, where guests perished trying to escape the flames, remains the epicenter of paranormal activity. Former owner Durward Hoag, who managed the hotel from 1931 to 1973 and lived on the third floor, continues his vigilant watch over the property. Staff and guests regularly encounter Mr. Hoag’s spirit in the Gun Room restaurant, where servers mistake him for a living patron sitting in his favorite corner booth until he vanishes.
His presence manifests through exploding lightbulbs, flickering lights, and the overwhelming sensation of being watched. The basement harbors three additional spirits, including a mischievous woman who locks bathroom doors and manipulates lights, and a small boy seen wandering the corridors.
Hidden Marietta operates from the basement, offering ghost tours that explore these active areas where footsteps echo in empty hallways, doors open autonomously, and furniture mysteriously rearranges itself.
Hidden Marietta
Address: 424 George St, Marietta, OH 45750
Phenomenons reported: Feeling of being watched, Moving objects, Shadow figures
Why it's Haunted
Hidden Marietta operates from the magnificent 1859 Anchorage mansion at 424 George Street, where owner Douglas Putnam’s Italianate masterpiece has become Ohio’s premier ghost tour headquarters and paranormal investigation venue.
Built by Douglas Putnam, great-grandson of Revolutionary War General Israel Putnam, for his wife Eliza, the 22-room mansion sits dramatically atop a hill overlooking Marietta while serving as both the tour company’s base and an active supernatural investigation site.
Visitors report hearing ‘low grumbles’ and unexplained sounds during tours of the atmospheric mansion, where overnight paranormal investigations allow guests to use their own equipment while exploring the building’s mysterious energy. The company’s tours extend beyond the mansion to include the nearby Lafayette Hotel, originally built in 1892 as the Bellevue Hotel before being destroyed by fire in 1916 and rebuilt in 1918.
The Lafayette harbors Durwin Hoag, the former owner from 1931-1973 who died in 1982 and continues to haunt the second floor and Gun Room restaurant, while the third floor experiences the most intense paranormal activity. A Victorian-dressed woman appears throughout the hotel, vanishing after being spotted, while guests report misplaced belongings, moving shadows, and the sensation of being watched by unseen presences who maintain eternal residence in these historic Marietta establishments.
Haunted Hotels in Put-In-Bay, OH
Historic Park Hotel
Address: 234 Delaware Ave, Put-In-Bay, OH 43456
Phenomenons reported: Child spirits, Apparitions, Disembodied voices, Doors opening/closing, Feeling of being watched, Moving objects
Why it's Haunted
Historic Park Hotel has welcomed guests to Put-In-Bay island since the 1870s, accumulating tragic spirits within its grand Victorian walls that create one of Ohio’s most authentically haunted accommodations on Lake Erie.
The hotel’s most prominent spirit, known as ‘the governess,’ tragically fell from the second floor down the steps to the lobby and died, her maternal ghost now residing primarily in Room 14 where she demonstrates particular affection for children staying at the hotel. Local island children playing in the lobby report feeling ‘watched over’ by this benevolent spirit who continues her caretaking duties from beyond the grave.
Room 17 harbors the darker presence of an early bar owner who committed suicide by hanging in the third floor stairwell, his tormented spirit looking down on guests in their beds and peering from the window while also visiting the Winter Bar located next to the lobby.
Recent guests have experienced closet doors moving on their own in Room 11, accompanied by shuffling noises and the overwhelming feeling of being watched, activity so intense that a hotel employee moved out of the room due to repeated supernatural encounters.
The Victorian establishment resonates with ghostly ballroom music from unknown sources, 1920s-30s melodies, and conversations between two men when no living persons are present, while apparitions in period clothing traverse the halls of this island sanctuary where the dead continue their eternal vacation.
Haunted Hotels in Cleveland, OH
The Franklin Castle (Hannes Tiedemann House)
Address: 4308 Franklin Blvd, Cleveland, OH 44113
Phenomenons reported: Apparitions, Child spirits, Feeling of being watched, Phantom footsteps, Phantom music, Unexplained screams/crying
Why it's Haunted
The Franklin Castle stands as Cleveland’s most infamous haunted mansion, where German immigrant Hannes Tiedemann’s 1881 architectural masterpiece became a monument to family tragedy and supernatural persistence that continues to fascinate paranormal investigators.
The four-story, 20-room mansion witnessed devastating losses including daughter Emma’s death from diabetes in 1881, elderly mother Wiebeka’s passing months later, four children dying over the years, and wife Louise’s death from liver disease in 1895, creating a concentrated atmosphere of grief and loss.
The castle’s most frequently reported spirit is the ‘Woman in Black,’ believed to be connected to the family’s tragic losses, who stares from the front tower window and appears throughout the house as a mourning figure dressed in dark clothing.
Visitors experience babies crying throughout the night, footsteps echoing through empty corridors, screams in hallways, and phantom organ music despite no organ being present, while ceiling lamps turn on their own and ghostly figures manifest throughout the rooms.
Featured on paranormal television including ‘Paranormal Lockdown’ and ‘Ghost Adventures,’ the castle offers occasional overnight accommodations where guests can experience firsthand the supernatural legacy of a family whose love for their home transcended death, creating one of Ohio’s most documented examples of residential haunting where architectural grandeur meets eternal sorrow.
Haunted Hotels in Granville, OH
Historic Buxton Inn
Address: 313 E Broadway, Granville, OH 43023
Phenomenons reported: Lady in Blue apparition, Apparitions, Disembodied voices, Doors opening/closing, Feeling of being watched, Phantom footsteps
Why it's Haunted
Historic Buxton Inn stands as Ohio’s oldest continuously operating inn, where 212 years of hospitality have created a supernatural staff of former owners and beloved employees who refuse to abandon their earthly duties. Built in 1812 by pioneer Orrin Granger as Granville’s first post office and stagecoach stop, the inn gained its current name from Major Buxton and his wife who acquired the property in 1865 and whose spirits continue their proprietorial oversight.
The inn’s most beloved ghost, Ethel ‘Bonnie’ Bounell, appears as the Lady in Blue throughout rooms and hallways, her gentle blue apparition reflecting her favorite color while demonstrating the love she felt for the establishment where she served as innkeeper before dying in Room 9.
Major Buxton manifests alongside the distinct aroma of cigar smoke, maintaining his presence throughout the building he once owned, while original builder Orrin Granger occasionally appears to guests and staff.
Room 9 experiences the most concentrated paranormal activity, housing both the Lady in Blue and Houston’s ghostly cat, who jumps on beds, cuddles with guests, and creates the sensation of purring without any physical feline being present.
The inn resonates with unexplained footsteps in empty hallways, names being called out by disembodied voices, sudden cold drafts, and heavy doors that slam shut and open without human intervention, while distinguished guests including Abraham Lincoln, Henry Ford, and President William Henry Harrison add historical gravitas to its supernatural legacy.
Haunted Hotels in Aurora, OH
The Aurora Inn Hotel & Event Center
Address: 30 Shawnee Trail, Aurora, OH 44202
Phenomenons reported: Apparitions, Feeling of being watched
Why it's Haunted
The Aurora Inn Hotel & Event Center operates as a renovated hospitality establishment in Aurora, Ohio, serving guests within a community rich with supernatural folklore and local ghost stories, though specific paranormal activity at this particular location remains undocumented in regional haunted hotel directories.
The property’s position in northeastern Ohio places it within a geographical area known for its historical significance and spiritual energy, where numerous other accommodations and historic sites have documented supernatural phenomena.
While the Aurora Inn itself may not appear on official haunted location lists, its role as a gathering place for travelers means it has accumulated years of human energy and emotional experiences that sensitive individuals may detect during their stays. The hotel’s focus on events and conferences creates an environment where countless personal celebrations, business gatherings, and social interactions have occurred, potentially leaving residual energy that could manifest in subtle ways.
Guests interested in paranormal activity might find that their heightened awareness leads to experiences that, while not dramatically supernatural, suggest the presence of spiritual energy common to hospitality establishments with long histories of human activity.
Haunted Hotels in Newbury Township, OH
Punderson Manor Lodge & Conference Center
Address: 11755 Kinsman Rd, Newbury Township, OH 44065
Phenomenons reported: Child spirits, EVP recordings, Apparitions, Cold spots, Disembodied voices, Doors opening/closing
Why it's Haunted
Punderson Manor Lodge & Conference Center stands among Ohio’s most intensely haunted accommodations, where multiple tragedies spanning over a century have created a supernatural community that actively interacts with living guests and staff.
The manor’s haunted legacy begins with original owner Lemuel Punderson’s 1822 death, though the dramatic story of his suicide by rowing a bathtub to the lake’s center and pulling the plug has been romanticized from his actual death due to malaria complications. The property’s most spectacular supernatural manifestation occurred in the late 1970s when multiple staff members witnessed a lumberjack spirit hanging by the neck from rafters in what is now the lounge, swinging for three hours until sunrise in a display that cemented the manor’s haunted reputation.
The Windsor Suite has earned distinction as the most paranormally active accommodation, while throughout the building, fireplaces extinguish themselves, pencils fly through the air, doors open and close without cause, and faucets operate under invisible control.
A tragic attic fire in the 1900s that killed a father and two little girls, combined with a party boat that sank on the lake drowning several people, has layered additional spiritual energy onto the property.
Formal paranormal investigations in 2005 captured clear EVP recordings and documented 10-degree temperature drops, while guests regularly experience the woman’s disembodied voice and laughter echoing from the circular staircase in this manor where the dead maintain their eternal residence.
Find other Haunted Hotels in America
Click your state to find a Haunted Hotel near you.
*Blacked Out States = No Haunted Hotel Locations*