Haunted Hotels in Indiana
Haunted Places to Stay in Indiana
Indiana’s 5 haunted accommodations preserve spirits from the Underground Railroad, Civil War home front, and industrial development that transformed the Hoosier State. When you search for haunted hotels online or on Google Maps, you’ll find over 33,000 matching results, but we’ve meticulously reviewed every single one to create the most realistic, historically accurate collection of truly haunted hotels you can actually visit and stay in.
These properties harbor souls of freedom seekers, war casualties, factory workers, and rural families whose lives intersected with major historical movements through America’s heartland. Discover Midwestern hauntings where abolitionist sacrifice meets industrial progress, creating paranormal encounters that reflect Indiana’s role in America’s moral and economic evolution.
Table of Contents
Haunted Hotels in Atlanta, IN
Roads Hotel
Address: 150 E Main St, Atlanta, IN 46031
Phenomenons reported: Prohibition Era Brothel Murder Sarah; Roads Family Tuberculosis Deaths; John Dillinger and Al Capone Criminal Activity; Queen Anne Mansion Natural Gas Boom Ghosts; Speakeasy Violence Paranormal Activity
Why it's Haunted
Built in 1893 as an elegant Queen Anne-style mansion during Indiana’s natural gas boom, the Roads Hotel became forever haunted when owners Newton and Clara Roads transformed their respectable inn into a Prohibition-era speakeasy and brothel that attracted notorious criminals like John Dillinger and Al Capone while harboring the violent murder of prostitute Sarah by a brutal customer during the lawless 1920s.
The hotel’s dark history intensified when multiple members of the Roads family died from tuberculosis within its walls, including Newton in 1926, his son Everett, wife Clara, and stepmother Catherine, their illness-ravaged spirits now manifesting through disembodied voices, phantom footsteps, and doors that open and close by themselves throughout the National Register historic property.
Sarah’s murdered spirit haunts the upper floors where she died violently, her ghostly presence creating disembodied screams, mysterious knocks, door rattling, and supernatural conversations from another era that paranormal investigators document as residual activity replaying her tragic final moments. Featured on Ghost Adventures, Ghost Hunters, and Paranormal Investigators as Indiana’s third most haunted location, the Roads Hotel harbors apparitions of men, women, and children who died during the building’s transformation from respectable lodging to criminal haven, while electromagnetic voice phenomena recordings capture more supernatural communications than most haunted locations.
The former 22-room inn now operates exclusively for paranormal investigations benefiting the Lost Limbs Foundation, where overnight ghost hunts reveal shadow figures, mists, orbs, and the continuing presence of the Roads family who died caring for guests and now eternally tend to visitors from beyond the grave, making this Atlanta, Indiana landmark a concentrated supernatural repository of Prohibition violence, family tragedy, and criminal enterprise.
Haunted Hotels in Indianapolis, IN
Historic Hannah House
Address: 3801 Madison Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46227
Phenomenons reported: Alexander Hannah Quaker Abolitionist Ghost; Underground Railroad Legend Fire Deaths; Basement Burning Flesh Phantom Smells; Elizabeth Hannah Stillborn Baby Spirit; Civil War Era Enslaved People Apparitions
Why it's Haunted
Built in 1858 by Alexander Moore Hannah, a Quaker businessman and abolitionist, this 24-room mansion has become forever haunted by the tragic legend of enslaved people who allegedly died in a basement fire when a lantern was accidentally knocked over during their escape through the Underground Railroad, though historians emphasize this story is an unsubstantiated urban myth that damages the true history of slavery in Indiana.
Despite the questionable historical foundation, the Hannah House remains one of Indiana’s most paranormally active locations where visitors consistently report the phantom smell of burning flesh emanating from the cellar, apparitions of enslaved runaways who died seeking freedom, and the ghostly presence of Alexander Hannah himself appearing as a man in a black suit walking the upstairs hallway.
The mansion harbors multiple spirits including a woman who appears near the second-floor window, the ghost of Elizabeth Hannah’s stillborn baby whose cries echo through empty rooms, and shadowy figures that manifest throughout the property as witnesses to both documented history and persistent supernatural legends. Paranormal investigators document typical haunted phenomena including unexplained noises, lights and electronic devices turning on and off by themselves, objects moving independently, and the overwhelming sense of tragic loss permeating the basement where the alleged deaths occurred.
Now operating as a historic site offering monthly open house tours and overnight paranormal investigations for $45 per person, Hannah House continues attracting both history enthusiasts and ghost hunters seeking to experience the supernatural activity that has made this Indianapolis landmark famous for blending documented 19th-century history with enduring paranormal mysteries, making it a haunted testament to Indiana’s complex relationship with slavery, abolition, and the persistent power of tragic legends to create supernatural manifestations.
Fort Harrison Inn
Address: 5830 N Post Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46216
Phenomenons reported: Fort Benjamin Harrison Military Base Hospital Ghosts; World War Korea Vietnam Soldier Patient Spirits; Disembodied Voices Laughter Corridor Phantoms; Mysterious Vapor Cloud Stairwell Apparitions; Front Desk Staff Acknowledged Supernatural Reports
Why it's Haunted
Originally serving as the base hospital for Fort Benjamin Harrison military post established in 1906 until the fort’s closure in 1995, the Fort Harrison Inn became forever haunted by the countless soldiers, medical staff, and patients who died within its walls during nearly nine decades of military medical operations, their spirits refusing to abandon the converted hospital where they experienced both healing and death during some of America’s most significant military conflicts including both World Wars, Korea, and Vietnam.
The inn’s supernatural legacy intensified through its transformation from active military hospital to state park accommodation, creating a unique haunted destination where front desk staff openly acknowledge multiple reports of strange things being seen, heard, and felt throughout the historic building, while guests consistently request room changes after encountering overwhelming ghostly presences that make overnight stays unbearable for sensitive visitors.
The property’s most documented paranormal activity includes disembodied voices and laughter echoing through corridors, mysterious vapor clouds rising in stairwells before vanishing, and the persistent sensation of invisible presences that drive guests to flee their rooms and seek alternative accommodations, manifestations that reflect the institutional suffering of military personnel who died far from home during medical treatment.
Located within Fort Harrison State Park on 1,700 acres of former military grounds, the inn operates as both state park lodging with 18-hole golf course and restaurant while serving as an unintentional paranormal destination where the boundary between military history and supernatural activity creates authentic ghostly encounters rather than manufactured haunted attractions.Â
Haunted Hotels in Mitchell, IN
Whispers Estate
Address: 714 W Warren St, Mitchell, IN 47446
Phenomenons reported: Victorian Era Doctor John Gibbons Ghost; Christmas Fire Death Rachael; Medical Practice Patient Deaths; Infant Elizabeth and Jessie Gibbons Pneumonia Spirits; Travel Channel 4th Most Terrifying Place
Why it's Haunted
Built in 1894 as a Victorian mansion for Dr. George and Sarah White before being sold to Dr. John and Jessie Gibbons in 1899, Whispers Estate became forever haunted when multiple tragic deaths occurred within its walls, including ten-year-old adopted daughter Rachael who died on Christmas morning 1921 when her nightgown caught fire while she was sneaking downstairs to peek at presents under the Christmas tree.
The estate harbors nearly two dozen spirits, many of whom were patients who died during Dr. Gibbons’ 26-year medical practice operated from the first floor, their suffering souls now manifesting through whispered voices, inappropriate touching, and supernatural encounters that earned the location recognition as America’s ‘4th Most Terrifying Place’ by the Travel Channel in 2010.
Dr. Gibbons himself haunts the premises as a malevolent spirit known for whispering in young women’s ears and grabbing visitors inappropriately, while infant Elizabeth who died of unknown causes shares the same room where Jessie Gibbons later succumbed to pneumonia, their deaths creating a concentrated supernatural presence in the upstairs chambers.
The mansion’s paranormal activity intensifies around doorknobs that jiggle mysteriously before doors open by themselves, growling sounds emanating from the second-floor servants’ quarters, and physical encounters including pants being pulled and visitors being touched by invisible hands throughout the three-story attic spaces.
Featured on multiple television paranormal specials and offering flashlight tours, mini-investigations, and full overnight paranormal investigations, Whispers Estate stands as Mitchell, Indiana’s most haunted location where decades of medical practice, family tragedy, and unexplained deaths created a supernatural concentration of restless spirits who continue terrorizing visitors seeking to experience the Victorian mansion’s dark legacy of death and supernatural manifestations.
Haunted Hotels in Winchester, IN
Official Randolph County Asylum/Infirmary
Address: 1882 US-27, Winchester, IN 47394
Phenomenons reported: Basement Suicide Woman Tortured Spirit; Second Story Window Push Murder Victim; Tuberculosis Outbreak Multiple Death Phantoms; Children Orphan Giggling Footsteps Ghosts; Poor Farm Asylum Neglect Cruelty Spirits
Why it's Haunted
Built in 1899 as the third structure on this site after the first building burned and the second melted away from improperly fired bricks, the Official Randolph County Asylum/Infirmary became forever haunted when it served as poor farm, asylum, and infirmary housing over 1,487 people throughout its operational history until closing in 2006, witnessing approximately 200 deaths including suicides, tuberculosis outbreaks, accidents, and a mysterious murder when one man was pushed from a second-story window after threatening to expose neighbors’ nefarious activities.
The facility’s paranormal epicenter is the basement where raw sewage created horrific living conditions and one woman committed suicide, her tortured spirit joining the restless souls of tuberculosis victims who died during multiple infectious disease outbreaks that swept through the overcrowded institution during the late 1800s and early 1900s when medical care was primitive and death rates soared among society’s most vulnerable residents.
The asylum harbors countless spirits from different eras including orphans, elderly poor, and mentally ill patients who experienced neglect, cruelty, and torturous practices within walls designed to provide sanctuary but instead delivering suffering and death, their collective presence creating supernatural phenomena including slamming doors, children’s giggling, little footsteps in hallways, women screaming, and crashing sounds echoing through the cafeteria and basement areas.
Operating now under owner Dann Allen’s nonprofit STOP (Save the Old Properties) as a paranormal investigation destination offering overnight stays for groups up to 10 people, the facility provides two-hour guided tours highlighting the most active supernatural locations before leaving visitors alone until morning to experience firsthand the concentrated spiritual energy of those who died forgotten and uncared for.
Find other Haunted Hotels in America
Click your state to find a Haunted Hotel near you.
*Blacked Out States = No Haunted Hotel Locations*