Haunted Hotels in Nebraska
Haunted Places to Stay in Nebraska
Nebraska’s 2 haunted hotels preserve Great Plains pioneer struggles, where homesteading failures and agricultural disasters created unexpected supernatural concentrations in America’s breadbasket. When you search for haunted hotels online or on Google Maps, you’ll find over 33,000 matching results, but we’ve meticulously reviewed every single one to create the most realistic, historically accurate collection of truly haunted hotels you can actually visit and stay in.
These prairie properties house spirits of failed farmers, Union Pacific railroad casualties, and the psychological toll of endless horizons on settlers unprepared for plains life. Experience heartland hauntings where agricultural dreams meet environmental reality, creating paranormal encounters that reflect the hidden desperation beneath America’s farming prosperity.
Table of Contents
Haunted Hotels in Chadron, NE
Olde Main Street Inn
Address: 115 Main St, Chadron, NE 69337
Phenomenons reported: General Nelson Miles Wounded Knee Investigation Headquarters; Uncle Jack Prankster Moving Objects Slamming Doors; Anna Red Satin Dress Beautiful Woman Apparition; St. Patrick’s Day 1892 Mysterious Green Beer; Railroad YMCA Thirty Years Guardian Spirits
Why it's Haunted
Built in 1890 by the O’Hanlon family as the Chadron House and serving as headquarters for General Nelson Miles during his December 30, 1890 investigation of the Wounded Knee massacre, which he called ‘the most abominable criminal military blunder and horrible massacre of women and children,’ the Olde Main Street Inn became forever haunted by two guardian spirits whose friendly pranks and protective presence transformed this National Register landmark into Nebraska’s most welcoming supernatural accommodation.
The inn harbors the playful ghost of Uncle Jack, a prankster whose spirit continues his earthly mischief by moving objects from spot to spot, slamming doors mysteriously, creating disembodied footsteps, and breaking pitchers at the bar when nobody is around, while owner Jeanne Gotzinger witnessed him standing by the saloon window at 5:30 AM before vanishing when she looked back.
The property’s most beautiful spirit is Anna, Jack’s sister who appears only to gentlemen as a stunning woman with long dark hair wearing a red satin dress, her elegant apparition manifesting throughout the building alongside Jack’s pranks that include mysteriously turning beer green on St. Patrick’s Day 1992 and blowing the front door wide open without warning as the sibling spirits maintain their eternal connection to the hotel’s green and gold wallpaper era.
Featured in paranormal investigations by Haunted Nebraska with EVP recordings and filming evidence, the Olde Main Street Inn embraces its reputation as a haunted bed and breakfast with nine rooms and the Longbranch Saloon, where guests experience guardian spirit protection rather than alarming encounters as Jack and Anna continue their eternal hospitality duties in this Chadron landmark that bridges Wounded Knee investigation headquarters with friendly frontier ghost stories, making it Nebraska’s most historically significant and supernaturally welcoming haunted accommodation where military tragedy investigation and sibling spirit pranks create an atmosphere of protective haunting rather than frightening encounters.
Haunted Hotels in Broken Bow, NE
Historic Arrow & East Hotels
Address: 509 S 9th Ave, Broken Bow, NE 68822
Phenomenons reported: Room 205 Most Haunted Former Owner Death Management; Red-Haired Witch Ivy Madison Square Cemetery Murder; Railway 1928 First Three-Story Building Broken Bow; Grey-Haired Apparition Cigar Room Ghostly Man; Conjuring Level Skeptic Conversion Paranormal Activity
Why it's Haunted
Built in 1928 by private citizens as Broken Bow’s first three-story building to service railroad needs, replacing the old Commercial Hotel with fifty-two sleeping rooms, street-level lobby, restaurant, beauty salon, barbershop, dress shop, and ballroom, the Historic Arrow Hotel became forever haunted when the former owner died within its walls and chose to continue his eternal management duties through supernatural manifestations that created one of Nebraska’s most intensely haunted locations.
The hotel’s paranormal epicenter is Room 205, recognized as the most haunted accommodation where guests experience furniture moving independently, strange booms echoing late at night from empty areas, lights turning on randomly throughout the building, and cupboard doors opening mysteriously in unoccupied rooms as the deceased owner’s spirit maintains his property management responsibilities from beyond the grave.
The property harbors multiple additional spirits including a grey-haired apparition wandering the building after closing hours, a ghostly man who sits in the cigar room smoking invisible cigars, and most mysteriously, a red-haired woman appearing in upstairs hallways believed to be the murdered spirit of a witch named Ivy buried in nearby Madison Square cemetery whose violent death created vengeful energy that manifests through curtains opening unexpectedly, broken doors slamming independently, and shadow figures terrifying guests who never believed in supernatural encounters before staying at the Arrow Hotel.
Recent guest testimonials document unprecedented paranormal activity including knocking sounds, physical interactions with curtains and doors, closet doors opening spontaneously, and shadow figure manifestations so intense that skeptical visitors become believers after experiencing ‘conjuring level’ supernatural encounters that transform disbelief into terror.
Operating today as a gorgeous and highly-ranked accommodation that embraces its haunted reputation while providing quality lodging, the Historic Arrow Hotel stands as Nebraska’s premier supernatural destination where railroad hospitality, property owner devotion, and nearby cemetery violence created a haunted concentration that transforms visitors from skeptics to believers through overwhelming paranormal encounters in America’s heartland’s most actively haunted railroad hotel.
Find other Haunted Hotels in America
Click your state to find a Haunted Hotel near you.
*Blacked Out States = No Haunted Hotel Locations*